Sports

Paris loss a useful warning for Springboks ahead of 2027 World Cup

The Springboks' 21–19 loss to France in Paris exposed problems with discipline and accuracy, but one columnist argues it came at a useful time.

The Springboks went down 21–19 to France at the Stade de France on Friday night. According to IOL columnist Mike Greenaway, the result is painful but may prove valuable, with the World Cup defence in Australia about 11 months away.

What went wrong in Paris

Greenaway describes the match as a display of poor discipline and inaccuracy from the South Africans. By his count, the Boks gave away six turnovers before the break and made six knock-ons in total. Italian referee Andrea Piardi also penalised them repeatedly.

France’s rush defence caused further trouble. It forced the Springbok backs to receive the ball behind the advantage line, and Greenaway says Rassie Erasmus and his staff must find a better answer to that speed and aggression.

The columnist also points to France’s use of Antoine Dupont. Although Dupont wore the No 10 jersey, he spent much of the night at scrumhalf, while Maxime Lucu handled first-receiver duties.

Dominant scrum, no reward

The Springbok scrum, both starters and replacements, had the French in serious difficulty. That dominance did not turn into points, though. France lost three players to yellow cards and were down to 14 men for 28 minutes after the break, yet they scored nothing after half-time and still held on.

One French try came from a freak moment, when a pass hit Kalvin Gourgues in the face and the ball ran loose, allowing Théo Attissogbe to score. Erasmus said afterwards: “I’m not sure how you defend the ball bouncing off a face.” Greenaway’s view is that the Boks should have built a big enough lead for such an incident not to matter. Manie Libbok then missed a conversion with seven minutes left, which meant the Boks could not even level the scores.

Erasmus said he was not blaming the match officials, but he made clear he was unhappy with some decisions. Greenaway notes that the referee was reluctant to punish the French scrum despite the pressure on it.

Lessons and what comes next

Greenaway says Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu, who impressed against Italy in Turin a week earlier, learnt how hard it is to run a Test when the opposition gives no time or space. He says Morné van den Berg faced a similar test with his box kicks against a charging French pack.

The columnist also stresses that France are back-to-back Six Nations champions and beat the reigning world champions without several key players. It was their first home win over South Africa since 2005, and only their second in 11 meetings.

His conclusion is that the Boks cannot rely on reputation or past achievements. With almost a year left to fix the weaknesses shown in Paris, he argues, it is far better to find them now than in a World Cup knockout match.

This story is based on reporting by IOL.