Sports

IOL column: Springboks should start Malcolm Marx in big Tests

An IOL column argues the Springboks should start Malcolm Marx in their biggest Tests after the 21-19 Nations Championship defeat to France in Paris.

Malcolm Marx is too important to the Springboks to be used as a replacement in their biggest matches, according to an opinion column by Leighton Koopman on IOL. The piece was published after the Boks lost 21-19 to France in Paris in the Nations Championship.

The argument for starting Marx

The column describes the World Rugby Player of the Year as possibly the most valuable member of the Springbok pack. Koopman writes that, for as long as no other hooker comes close to what Marx offers, he should be in the starting side against New Zealand, France, England and Ireland.

Jan-Hendrik Wessels started at hooker against France and scored a try from a rolling maul. The column says he played well. Even so, it argues that the Boks looked like a different team once Marx arrived, roughly 35 minutes into the match, together with props Wilco Louw and Ox Nché.

IOL’s writer points to Marx’s work at the breakdown, his defence, his ball-carrying and his leadership as key parts of the Springbok game. He says Marx helps set the physical tone alongside loose forward Pieter-Steph du Toit.

Depth versus results

The column accepts that coach Rassie Erasmus had reasons to test Wessels and props Gerhard Steenekamp and Thomas du Toit from the start. Building depth and giving players chances matter, it says. But it questions whether a match against France, with Marx and the first-choice props available, was the right moment to experiment with the front row.

On the other options, Koopman writes that Bongi Mbonambi is probably the closest alternative, but that he is still returning to top form after a long spell out. Wessels is described as a player with potential who is still finding his feet at Test level. The column says the remaining hookers have not yet shown they can match Marx’s impact on a regular basis.

France led 21-7 at half-time, and the column says the Boks’ late comeback fell just short. It argues that the Boks cannot afford to hand strong opponents an early advantage.

Using Marx from the bench as part of the so-called Bomb Squad can hurt tiring teams, the writer concedes. But he says that only works if another hooker can sustain the same level for the first 40 to 50 minutes, and he believes that is not the case at present.

Looking to 2027

Koopman accepts that Erasmus must keep building depth ahead of the 2027 Rugby World Cup. His conclusion, however, is that Marx should be among the first names on the team sheet when the biggest Tests come around. He argues that leaving him out of the starting line-up cost the Boks in Paris.

This is the columnist’s opinion, and the Springbok coaching staff have their own selection priorities.

This story is based on reporting by IOL.