Entertainment

Usimamane says Pretoria doesn’t produce stars, reigniting rivalry debate

Durban rapper Usimamane has revived the Pretoria versus Durban hip-hop debate by arguing that his hometown produces bigger stars than the capital.

A studio clip of Durban rapper Usimamane has set off another round of the Pretoria versus Durban argument in South African hip-hop, according to SA Hip Hop Mag. The footage began circulating on Friday.

What he said

The Umlazi-born artist was asked for his view on the regional rivalry. He did not take a neutral line. Instead, he challenged Pretoria’s supporters to point to a rapper in the capital who is bigger than Nasty C, Blxckie or himself. His conclusion was blunt: “They don’t make stars.”

Another version of the clip is also doing the rounds online. In it, he appears to temper the remark a little, adding: “I mean they don’t make stars respectfully.”

How fans responded

The clip quickly moved to X, where opinion was split. Some users agreed with him, citing the success and visibility of Nasty C and Blxckie, as well as Usimamane’s own rising profile. Others felt he had undersold Pretoria’s role in the culture, and some pointed to A-Reece as an example of a star from the capital.

SA Hip Hop Mag notes that the rivalry is one of the best-known regional conversations in local hip-hop. Durban has produced acts with big commercial success and international recognition, while Pretoria is known for its lyrical depth, its underground scene and its own distinct approach to the genre. The newest round of the debate comes down to what makes someone a star: sales and reach, cultural influence, lyrical skill, or all three.

Where Usimamane stands

The comments come as his career continues to build. His breakthrough arrived in 2024 with ‘Cheque’, a single that has been certified triple-platinum. The outlet describes him as one of the newer names in the national conversation, helping to keep Durban prominent in it.

It is not clear whether he meant the remarks as hometown pride, confidence in his own standing or friendly banter. The source does not say, and he has not been quoted explaining his intent beyond the clip.

For now, the next move belongs to Pretoria’s hip-hop community, and whether any artist responds directly remains to be seen. As SA Hip Hop Mag puts it, the strongest answer in hip-hop often comes through the music.

This story is based on reporting by SA Hip Hop Mag.